Bill Hoffman, staff.Photo Lisa Williams153801
Bill Hoffman, staff.Photo Lisa Williams153801

It’s time we worked out a less destructive path

BILL Hoffman is recovering from shoulder surgery so today we present one of his best columns from days gone by.

WHEN Joe Hockey declared the Age of Entitlement dead, Genie-like he let a question out of the bottle that is not going back unanswered.  

The question - just who has been entitled - is the biggest problem now facing the Abbott Government.  

Of course there are those in the ideologically-blinded right of the Coalition who thought the answer was obvious.

Clearly the poor sucking on the welfare teat, dole bludgers, scientists, academics, "lifestyle" aborigines, hospitality workers on penalty rate, humanities students and refugees were what the Treasurer was talking about.  

That's the problem though when you speak in headlines and three-word clichés. Occasionally, unintentionally, you may cause people to think beyond your dog whistle.  

And so it has come to pass.  

"What about them?" has been the electorate's response as it points back at politicians and their own jaw-droppingly generous entitlements, and at Rupert Murdoch whose US operations siphon off, all but tax-free, $4.5 billion from its Australian business and at aggressive tax-minimising miners and their diesel fuel rebates and at a development industry that cost shifts to the public sector at every available opportunity.   

Well may the so-called Group of Nine that includes the Business Council of Australia, the Australian Chamber of Commerce, Australian Food and Grocery Council, the Australian Industry Group, the Minerals Council of Australia, National Farmers Federation and the Property Council of Australia call for budget reform.  

But in the face of latest polling that places tax dodging and loss of penalty rates at the top of voter concern, there is feint hope that group of rent seekers will achieve the outcomes it wants.  

The Abbott Government is fast backing away from a budget widely perceived to target society's most vulnerable. It remains though to be seen if either the Prime Minister or Opposition leader Bill Shorten is capable of engaging voters in a frank discussion about this nation's future.  

Slick intergenerational reports and Minister Pyne education reform advertising won't cut it.   

Nor will a conversation high-jacked by one end of town to the exclusion of all others.  

We appear increasingly to have had enough of the demonization of the relatively few asylum seekers to wash up on our shores as the biggest threat to our sovereignty.  

Hopefully attention will turn to the 220,000 pouring through the front door annually and cause some at least to wonder whether there is more to their purpose than to prop up already inflated home prices.  

And also to the negative-gearing lark that has turned a once proud country with the research and intellectual capacity to create new things and industries and a broader economy, into little more than a game of Monopoly.  

It's a game of Monopoly aided as evidenced by recent ICAC inquiries in NSW and hopefully by one to come in Qld by strokes of government pens where at the point of which lies the greatest opportunity for corruption.   

I'm sure employing in the service sector as many young people on the cheapest rate for the minimum number of hours may make sense to some, but it doesn't guarantee service and it won't sustain an economy.  

And while there are clearly those who still believe in the fallacy of trickle-down economics, all empirical data would suggest the rich are getting richer and the rest are getting by.  

So let's have reform and let's have a conversation, make it truly about the Age of Entitlement and maybe we can find a path forward less destructive than the one we've been on.  


REVEALED: P&O’s next big 'Grand Class' Aussie ship

REVEALED: P&O’s next big 'Grand Class' Aussie ship

It will be the biggest ship ever to join P&O Australia’s fleet

Mature-aged dancers share secrets in intimate show

Mature-aged dancers share secrets in intimate show

'Hell, you are never too old to dance.'

Tesla chief’s crazy scheme to meet production targets

Tesla chief’s crazy scheme to meet production targets

The company is struggling to meet his ambitious production targets

Local Partners