Audi Q2, Mercedes-Benz GLA and BMW X2. Pictures: Thomas Wielecki
Audi Q2, Mercedes-Benz GLA and BMW X2. Pictures: Thomas Wielecki

Three-way comparison test: BMW X2 v Audi Q2 v Mercedes GLA

LUXURY sedans are becoming passe because buyers are downsizing to cars like these - high-riding hatchbacks that fit in tight parking spaces and have a commanding view of the road ahead.

Powered by zippy yet efficient turbo four-cylinder engines, these examples don't cost the earth to run - but do come with hefty price tags.

With the recent arrival of the BMW X2 it was time to get reacquainted with the Audi Q2 and Mercedes GLA. Here's how they compare.

AUDI Q2

Last time we tested the Audi Q2 it was criticised for being pricey. Now it undercuts the competition - we have the cheapest model in the range without any options, from $46,800 drive-away.

Standard fare includes dual zone airconditioning, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, built-in navigation and leather steering wheel with paddle-shifters.

Audi Q2: Cheapest of the trio but there are signs of cost-cutting. Pictures: Thomas Wielecki
Audi Q2: Cheapest of the trio but there are signs of cost-cutting. Pictures: Thomas Wielecki

The base Q2 lacks a power tailgate and a sensor key with push button start. It doesn't even get individual map lights - or lights for the vanity mirrors in the sun visors.

Unusual for an Audi, the centre console and door pockets are small. The rear door linings are finished in a cheap plastic while the front doors have better trim.

The air vents in the front work well but are presented in plain black plastic - it's apparent they're missing the alloy garnish of the dearer models. The control panel in the centre console that operates the audio and navigation is intuitive to use.

Generously sized, the boot has a wide and low load area and houses a space-saver spare under the floor (the others have run-flat tyres).

The 1.4-litre turbo might be the smallest engine here, with less grunt than the BMW, but the Audi is also lighter.

The X2 is about a second quicker to 100km/h but the Q2 is eager enough and delivers its power smoothly and quietly through the seven-speed twin-clutch auto driving the front wheels.

The suspension can be a touch busy over bumps but it's not jarring, and the steering is light yet precise - the best blend of agility and comfort among the trio.

 

MERCEDES-BENZ GLA

Mercedes was among the first luxury brands to join the city SUV brigade when the GLA arrived in 2014 ... which means the Benz is starting to show its age. We've tested the cheapest ticket into the line-up, the GLA 180 priced from $48,600 drive-away.

Mercedes GLA: Creature comforts but not too eager on the road
Mercedes GLA: Creature comforts but not too eager on the road

Despite delivering a level of comfort many can't match and packing a full suite of safety tech - including nine airbags, three more than the other pair - it lacks some basics.

The airconditioning is single zone and there are no rear air vents. The map pockets behind the front seats are mesh rather than fabric, so you can't stash valuables.

It does get creature comforts such as a sensor key with push button start, leather steering wheel with paddle-shifters and Apple CarPlay, Android Auto and built-in navigation.

Its 1.6-litre turbo is the least powerful in this trio in a body that is 100kg heavier than the Audi. It feels a little less eager than the Audi and against the BMW the power deficit is more apparent.

The GLA's twin-clutch transmission isn't as smooth or as intuitive as a regular auto - or the Audi's similar gearbox.

Unusual for a Mercedes, the tyres transmit a lot of road noise into the cabin and create more tyre slap over lane markers and expansion joins.

On the plus side, it's the most plush over bumps and the styling still looks fresh against newer rivals.

 

BMW X2

At $61,500 drive-away, the sDrive2.0i starts this contest at a disadvantage. It is the most expensive of the trio by a significant margin. A cheaper model is on the way - powered by a three-cylinder 1.5-litre turbo - but it's still about $10,000 more than the other two.

BMW X2: More style statement than practical hatch
BMW X2: More style statement than practical hatch

Fortunately it feels a step above the others as soon as you slip behind the wheel - fabrics and cabin upholstery are of a higher quality, there's mood lighting in the dash and doors at night and the seats feel both more cushioned and more sporty. There's more oomph under the bonnet, too, although once on the move the Audi isn't far behind.

It gains radar cruise control as standard but the rest of the equipment list is a bit hit and miss.

Apple CarPlay, standard on the rivals, adds $500 - after the initial three-year subscription BMW charges $150 a year for the smartphone mirroring. Android Auto isn't available yet.

There is another minor flaw in BMW's plan to appeal to younger buyers in the connected generation: there is only one USB charging port. Wireless phone charging is an optional extra.

In most cars with autonomous emergency braking, the vehicle comes to a complete stop to avoid a collision. The X2 has braking assistance that primes the brakes in an emergency and slows the car. BMW's fully fledged AEB is a $2600 optional extra bundled with a bigger navigation screen and head-up display.

Electric seat adjustment is part of a separate $2700 option pack. The list goes on.

On the road the 2.0-litre turbo feels perky but the suspension is a little too firm on bumpy back roads and the steering a touch too sharp.

Rear seat space is more snug than the other two - the X2 is definitely more of a style statement than a practical go-anywhere hatch.

 

VERDICT

BMW X2, Mercedes-Benz GLA and Audi Q2
BMW X2, Mercedes-Benz GLA and Audi Q2

The X2 is zippy to drive but its high price and lack of key features weigh against it. The GLA is best at cushioning bumps but the tyres are noisy, the gearbox is indecisive and the engine is lethargic. The Q2 wins because it has the most equipment for the least money and is easiest to live with day-to-day.

 

AUDI Q2 1.4TFSI

Q2: Intuitive control panel, steering is light but precise
Q2: Intuitive control panel, steering is light but precise

PRICE $46,800 drive-away

WARRANTY/SERVICE 3 years/unlimited km, 12 months/15,000km, $1590 over 3 years

ENGINE 1.4-litre 4-cyl turbo, 110kW/250Nm

SAFETY 5 stars, 6 airbags, AEB, rear camera, front and rear sensors

THIRST 5.3L/100km, 95 RON

SPARE Space-saver

BOOT 405L

 

BMW X2 sDrive2.0i

X2: Quality cabin feel but long list of expensive options
X2: Quality cabin feel but long list of expensive options

PRICE $61,500 drive-away

WARRANTY/SERVICE 3 years/unlimited km, service intervals condition based, $1495 over 3 years

ENGINE 2.0-litre 4-cyl turbo, 141kW/280Nm

SAFETY 5 stars, 6 airbags, emergency brake assist, rear camera, front and rear sensors

THIRST 6.0L/100km, 95 RON

SPARE None; run-flats

BOOT 470L

 

MERCEDES-BENZ GLA 180

GLA: Full suite of safety tech including nine airbags
GLA: Full suite of safety tech including nine airbags

PRICE $48,600 drive-away

WARRANTY/SERVICE 3 years/unlimited km, 12 months/25,000km, $1980 over 3 years

ENGINE 1.6-litre 4-cyl turbo, 90kW/200Nm

SAFETY 5 stars, 9 airbags, AEB, rear camera, front and rear sensors

THIRST 5.7L/100km, 95 RON

SPARE None; run-flats

BOOT 421L


Fabulous food touring in Thailand

Fabulous food touring in Thailand

Experience fine dining, culture, friendly locals and fantastic food.

Professor's inventive life has changed the world

Professor's inventive life has changed the world

His vital invention locks his name into the history books.

Brace yourselves: Cyclone Owen compared to 2013 disaster

Brace yourselves: Cyclone Owen compared to 2013 disaster

Qld is a tale of two states, from cyclone-born rain to droughts

Local Partners